Main Content

Property Search
Property Cape COD Real Estate


Broker / Owner
Specializing in Water & Luxury Property

I was raised on the Northside of Cape Cod, living in Barnstable Village, Cummaquid, West Barnstable and downtown Sandwich. I attended University of Massachusetts/Boston graduating with a Management Degree in Human Services. After graduating I moved away and lived in various parts of the country. But I missed the ocean air and beautiful scenery of Cape Cod, and so I moved back from Arizona in 2003, as the Cape and it’s shorelines repeatedly beckoned me home.

My career as a REALTOR started in 2005 and I began working with many high end buyers to help them find their dream waterfront home. My local knowledge of the Cape, coupled with my dedicated and honest approach has continued to fuel my career. I am focused and dedicated to marketing and selling properties along the shores of Cape Cod and beyond. I have sold many homes all over the Cape and this experience has made me an expert on the coastal home market.


Meet the team We can't wait to help you!

Our Cape Cod realtors value relationships, and are there to lend a helping hand or ear, offer advice, make recommendations, and help execute a plan regardless of the direction you decide to take. The culture of our company is built around what we can do for you to make life easier. Our agency is particular about who joins the Property Cape Cod realtor team, and so our real estate agents are selected not only on experience and expertise, but their moral compass, which has to align with our company culture. Our clients goals come first, Our Cape Cod realtor team works in your best interest, we earn your trust, we listen, we respect your property, we are honest and we love what we do – helping you!

Vacation Home Rentals
508.827.0165 Chris(at)PropertyCapeCod(dotted)com

WHAT OUR CLIENTS SAY Learn why you should work with us.

Working with Tia has been a pleasure. This is our 2nd successful business experience with Property Cape Cod, once for purchasing a vacation home, once for selling. She and her team work efficiently and smoothly...like a concierge at a 5 Star hotel, they act on every detail. Pleasant, friendly, knowledgeable, and experienced...these qualities along with their caring personalities and networking capacities have made our realty experience one of ease, comfort and success!

Nancy & John S.

East Falmouth

"Tia sold my in-law’s home in Marstons Mills, my brother’s home in Mashpee and she helped us purchase our vacation home in Popponesset. She's lovely and fun to work with and always incredibly responsive to questions. She truly just wants what's best for her clients and is not hesitant to provide important advice based on her years of experience. We highly recommend Tia and Property Cape Cod."

Laura and Rich B.

Beachfront, Popponessett

"Dawn was fantastic throughout our buying process, very competent and professional. She was helpful in so many ways, from consistently sending potential property matches, to advising us on presenting an offer, researching and finding info for us on special permitting needed and providing lots of town info. I would not hesitate to work with Dawn again or recommend her services."

Donna F.

Parker’s River, South Yarmouth

I couldn't be happier with Dawn as she went above and beyond for me. I would highly recommend her on the buy or sell side. We trust her so much that she is also managing our property for us.

Jason G.


"Everything was perfect. Karen was open and knowledgeable and I couldn't be happier. I was having a lot of trouble with the properties down the Cape and had a lot of negative experiences. I met with her on a whim one day and she picked out a few places to see and the second one was a hit, then and there. There was another offer on the table and we were able to compete with it and won the house. I am now on my second week in the home and that's what it is, it is a home. She even went the extra step with her husband to help fix one of the improvement items on my list and it couldn't be better. Thank you, Karen!"

Scott H.

West Yarmouth

"Karen is the most patient and hard working realtor, she never stops and always takes your call and questions and goes right to work researching. She puts her client's needs in front of her own. Additionally she is a great negotiator and finds great buys! Highly recommended."

Jake D.

West Yarmouth

"I cannot express in this review how happy we were to have Karen Lilly help us purchase our dream home on the Cape. From our first interactions with her, she had a very easy going, no pressure approach. She initially offered to show us other properties that may suit our needs, but then she quickly realized we had already fallen in love with this house. She helped us at every stage of the process, negotiating what we needed her to, and giving us any information we asked for. She went above and beyond by assisting us with other items related to the purchase, such as obtaining information about the dock situation, getting us all the contacts for the utilities, and nudging the lender along. We completely trusted her opinions and guidance. She really listened to us, and she was in tune with our needs from the very beginning. We highly recommend her."

Noelle and Tom S.

West Dennis

"A couple of years ago, my wife and I decided that we wanted to someday purchase a home on the Cape. We didn’t know exactly when this would happen, however we visit at least a few times a year traveling from Denver. We had a lot of work to do. As anxious people we started looking online for homes for sale. We were not ready. One home must have got our attention, and we made an inquiry. This is when we met Tia Lilly. What a find. Tia listened to us, as we explained what our plans for the future were. Boy, did she ever listen. We asked questions, she listened, we wanted information, she got it. We questioned ourselves, "Are we driving her crazy?" Tia insisted not. Instead we became friends that enjoyed each others’ company.

As time passed, we did what as needed to move forward. Earlier this year we found a house that would work for us. Tia made it happen. She not only made it happen, she made it so easy for us to close on the home. Now that we own the home, Tia is still making it happen or us. Living in Colorado, it is difficult to deal with everyday details of being a homeowner, Tia is still making it happen for us. If anyone looking to buy or sell a home, or is looking for an agent, (friend) look to Tia. "SHE WILL MAKE IT HAPPEN FOR YOU."

Rob L.


"Having purchased many homes in my life, I have learned that without the "right" real estate agent to look after your best interests, the process can be very stressful and difficult. Tia is an amazing agent. Her attention to detail and her ability to listen puts her at the top of all the real estate agents I have ever dealt with. We contacted her, explained to her what we were looking for and she went to work to find us the perfect home. She is extremely conscientious and detail oriented and did not stop working for us until every detail was taken care of right up to the point of closing. I would highly recommend her services to anyone buying or selling a home on Cape Cod."

Jackie and Mitchell G.

New Seabury

"Property Cape Cod Real Estate represents what a great real estate firm should be all about which is excellent Service, Expertise, and then on top of that some TLC! I used Tia Lilly as an agent in buying several vacation homes on the Cape and then hired her agency to manage my properties and summer rentals. I have lots of gray hair as I have bought and sold property in various states and overseas so I know an exceptional real estate firm when I experience it, and this is truly an exceptional real estate firm."

Michael & Olga B.

Beachfront, Truro and Dennis
Submit a Review See More +

featured videos Browse through some of our exclusive videos.

508.420.4200 627 South Main Street, Centerville, MA 02632

LIVE THE CAPE LIFE YOU IMAGINE. We can make it happen.